Pen Blind Boxes

Ready for the ultimate writing surprise?

Add a little mystery to your desk! Each order starts with 5 Pen Blind Boxes, with a different surprise waiting to be revealed inside each one.

From sleek and classic to colorful, cute, quirky, and whimsical, your pen haul can include all kinds of fun styles and designs. Even the ink is part of the mystery—you might uncover black, blue, colorful, gel, ballpoint, or other ink varieties.

You’re guaranteed to receive at least 5 unique mystery pens, making these perfect for planners, journal lovers, pen collectors, students, gifting—or anyone who can never have too many cute pens!

Find the Cream of the Cookie!

Five pens are just the beginning! Hidden inside some blind boxes is the special Cream of the Cookie charm. Reveal one and you’ve instantly scored a FREE BONUS PEN BLIND BOX! 🎉

That means your order may start with five…but with a little cookie luck, your mystery haul could keep growing!

Mystery Fine Print

Every order includes the contents of at least 5 Pen Blind Boxes.

At least 5 unique pens are guaranteed.

Pen styles, colors, designs, and ink types will vary.

No special requests for particular pens, colors, styles, or ink types—the mystery chooses for you!

Bonus boxes are not guaranteed and are awarded only when a Cream of the Cookie charm is revealed.

Display/storage box is not included.

All Mystery Blind Bag purchases are final sale. No returns, refunds, exchanges, substitutions, or swaps are available for mystery items based on personal preference, color, style, design, or duplicate/similar items.

Products may contain or come into contact with materials that could cause allergies or sensitivities. Cookie Crumbles Mystery Shop LLC is not responsible or liable for allergic reactions, sensitivities, irritation, or other reactions to products received. Please review individual product materials, ingredients, labels, and manufacturer information when applicable before use.

All orders are prepared and packaged in a dog-friendly environment. While care is taken when handling and packing orders, we cannot guarantee that packages or products will be completely free of pet hair, dander, or other pet-related allergens.

Once an order has been transferred to the shipping carrier, Cookie Crumbles Mystery Shop LLC is not responsible for packages or items that are lost, stolen, delayed, mishandled, or damaged during transit or after confirmed delivery.

By purchasing a Pen Blind Box order, you acknowledge and accept the surprise nature of mystery products and the terms above.

Start with five. Find the Cream. Unlock more.

Will the Cream of the Cookie be hiding in one of yours?

Order your Mystery Pen Blind Boxes and let the reveal begin!