Cookie Craze Mystery Cookies

How many cookies would you like to crumble?! Choose the size of your Cookie Craze order and get ready for a deliciously fun mystery!

Choose how many cookies and let fate do the rest. Each Cookie Craze Mystery Cookie is connected to one randomly selected surprise item from our ever-changing collection of fun, useful, and irresistible finds.

Your cookies could reveal stationery, beauty or self-care goodies, accessories, household finds, cozy lifestyle items, cute little treasures, or something completely unexpected. With new goodies being added and rotated regularly, you never quite know what your next cookie might bring.

But not every cookie is created equal...

Some cookies may lead to rare, premium, or extra-special treasures, turning an ordinary pick into a very lucky one. You won’t know what your cookie holds until it’s revealed—and that anticipation is half the fun!

Pick a few cookies for a little surprise, choose a bunch to see how lucky you are, or grab as many as you can and turn it into your own mystery adventure!

They’re perfect for treating yourself, gifting to someone who loves surprises, or simply bringing back that childhood excitement of opening something when you have absolutely no idea what’s inside.

With Cookie Craze, you pick the cookies... but the cookie picks your treasure!

A Little Mystery Fine Print 

Mystery really does mean mystery! Each cookie and its corresponding prize are selected at random, so specific products, colors, styles, or designs cannot be guaranteed. You may share your favorite color vibe, and we'll happily keep it in mind whenever possible, but preferences are not guaranteed.

We cannot accommodate dislike lists, item exclusions, swaps, or requests for specific products.

All Mystery Cookie purchases are final sale due to the surprise nature of the experience. No returns, refunds, or exchanges are available.

Products may contain or come into contact with materials that could cause allergies or sensitivities. Cookie Crumbles Mystery Shop LLC is not responsible or liable for allergic reactions, sensitivities, irritation, or other reactions to products received. Please review individual product materials, ingredients, labels, and manufacturer information when applicable before use.

All orders are prepared and packaged in a dog-friendly environment. While care is taken when handling and packing orders, we cannot guarantee that packages or products will be completely free of pet hair, dander, or other pet-related allergens.

Once an order has been transferred to the shipping carrier, Cookie Crumbles Mystery Shop LLC  is not responsible for packages or items that are lost, stolen, delayed, mishandled, or damaged during transit or after confirmed delivery. That being said, if you encounter a problem, please reach out to us so we can work together to ensure your mystery experience is an enjoyable one.

By purchasing Cookie Craze Mystery Cookies, you acknowledge and accept the surprise nature of mystery products and the terms above.

Every cookie holds a surprise. Every pick is a possibility. And you never know what treasure you’ll uncover.